A new Government – where to, employment law?

Whilst we await further announcements, our David Sorensen has reviewed the Conservative manifesto and other policy documents to work out the 6 steps most likely to be taken by the new Government in employment law:

1. Scrap the Human Rights Act and replace it with a British Bill of Rights – this will inevitably affect e.g. the way in which Employment Tribunals conduct themselves and the sort of arguments about privacy in email use/social media/misconduct cases in the unfair dismissal context.

2. Restrict strike laws further – bringing in a minimum turnout for industrial action of 40% of the workers entitled to vote within certain sectors (fire, transport, health and education), criminalisation of certain types of picketing, an extension in the length of a union’s required notice of industrial action from 7 to 14 days, a reduction in the ‘life span’ of industrial action ballots so as to require regular fresh ballots to be called, allowing employers to use agency workers to provide cover during a strike etc. All of these steps will inevitably make it even harder for unions to support workers who strike and increase the (already enormous) red tape unions face in these cases.

3. Restrict trade unions in other ways – increasing the regulation of union members’ subscriptions, reducing union representatives’ facility time in the workplace, reforming the Certification Officer’s role etc.

4. Keep ET fees – despite the evident unfairness (e.g. Vince Cable said just before the election “there is enough evidence to suggest that this was a very bad move and should be reversed. It is highly suggestive that the fees are discouraging people - particularly low paid women - from pursuing their rights”) it seems that, subject to any adverse Court of Appeal ruling in the ongoing Unison judicial review, ET fees may now be here to stay.

5. Pull out of the EU? The big question – if so, what happens to all the EU-sourced legislation such as the anti-discrimination laws, Equal Pay, TUPE, Collective redundancy consultation? Does it stay or also have to go?

6. There are some potentially positive measures (assuming they are implemented fairly and appropriately) – the ‘tackling’ of illegal working; the ‘encouragement’ of businesses to pay the ‘Living Wage’; a tax-free minimum wage by increasing a worker’s tax free personal allowance to £12,500; 3 days’ paid volunteers’ leave for employees in businesses with 250 employees or more or those employed throughout the public sector.

The direction of travel is clearly going to be anti-union and anti-industrial action. Access to justice for workers and employees is not going to be a priority. There are bound to be more employment law changes coming as well – will they revive the previous Adrian Beecroft report? That recommended cuts to maternity rights, a reduction in TUPE protection for transferring employees, increases to ET fees (e.g. from the currently high £1,200 to the extreme £3,750) as well as the removal of unfair dismissal protection and replacement with ‘No Fault Dismissal’. Time will tell.

David Sorensen - Partner

For further information on Employment Rights please visit our website or call 0033 3344 9603 and ask to speak with our Employment Rights team.